The 2023 BRAIS Prize in the Study of Islam and the Muslim World

 

The British Association for Islamic Studies (BRAIS) is delighted to announce the 2023 round of the BRAIS Prize in the Study of Islam and the Muslim World.

This international prize is awarded annually to the best doctoral thesis or unpublished first monograph based on a doctoral thesis. English-language submissions on any aspect of the academic study of Islam and the Muslim world, past and present, including Muslim-minority societies are accepted. Applicants can be based in any country, and manuscripts will be assessed on the basis of scholarly quality and originality.

The award includes a cash prize of £1000 which will be officially presented at the Annual Conference of BRAIS. The selection process will be undertaken by a nine-member prize committee comprising established academics from across the field. The winning candidate will be notified by August 2023.

Rules and Regulations: 

  1. To be eligible, a submission must either be a doctoral thesis, or an unpublished first monograph based on a doctoral thesis. The thesis must have been completed, successfully defended, and accepted no more than two years before the submission deadline. The thesis must have been submitted as part of the requirements for a doctoral degree at any university in the world.
  2. The subject(s) covered by the submission should fall within the remit of BRAIS. For details, see: www.brais.ac.uk/about-brais/about-us. The Prize Committee will make the final decision on whether submissions are of sufficient relevance.
  3. Submissions should not be scheduled for publication at any time before or during the competition.
  4. An award ceremony will be organised at the BRAIS Annual Conference.
  5. The BRAIS Prize is open to BRAIS members from any country. There is no age limit.
  6. Submissions are accepted in English only (with selections in other languages, where relevant), and must adhere to internationally recognised standards and conventions of academic writing, including of transliteration. Entries must include:
    1. Application form which can be downloaded here: BRAIS Prize 2023 Application Form (528.5 KB Word) 
    2. The manuscript. The minimum word limit is 80,000 words. There is no maximum limit. The thesis must be submitted in anonymised form, with all references to the author and his/her institution, acknowledgements and any other material that might help to identify the origins of the thesis removed, within reason. This is to maximise impartiality during the review process.
    3. The applicant’s curriculum vitae, of a maximum of 2 pages.
    4. A statement, of a maximum of 750 words, summarising the submission and highlighting its originality and contribution to the field.
    5. A scanned copy of the formal confirmation of the completion, successful defence and acceptance of the doctoral thesis from the awarding institution. If in doubt on the nature of this document, please enquire at your institution. 
  7. Items a-d should be submitted in PDF format. All files must contain the applicant’s surname in the file name. Documents must be submitted to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. by 5pm GMT Tuesday 28 February 2023
  8. The applicant should also arrange for the supervisor or another academic, who is more senior than the applicant and is familiar with the submission, to submit a supporting statement that highlights its contributions to the field. This should be submitted by the supervisor or senior academic confidentially and directly to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. by 5pm Tuesday 28 February 2023. The full name of the applicant should be stated in the title of the email.
  9. Failure to follow all submission requirements will result in an automatic disqualification.

All submissions are vigorously and anonymously reviewed by experts in the relevant field. The reports from reviewers help the Prize Committee to undertake the selection process.

 

The Prize Committee

Anthony Allison (University of Glasgow)

Omar Anchassi (University of Bern)

Sariya Cheruvallil-Contractor (Coventry University)

Robert Gleave (University of Exeter)

Jon Hoover (University of Nottingham)

Carool Kersten (KU Leuven)

Anna McSweeny (Trinity College Dublin, University of Dublin)

Judith Pfeiffer (University of Bonn)

Saeko Yazaki (University of Glasgow), Chair

 

Prize Coordinator

Adam Ramadhan (Al-Mahdi Institute)

 

Former Prize Committee Members

Glaire Anderson (University of Edinburgh)

Nicolai Sinai (Oxford University)

James Piscatori (Durham University)

Sophie Gilliat-Ray (Cardiff University)

Ayman Shihadeh (SOAS, University of London), Chair 2016-2018

The Prize Committee wishes to convey its gratitude to Dr Ayman Shihadeh for his hard work and unfailing patience as Chair during the initial years of the Prize, and for his vision in establishing it in collaboration with De Gruyter. 

The BRAIS Prize was originally called the BRAIS-De Gruyter Prize until 2022 and the BRAIS Officers and Prize Committee would like to express special thanks to De Gruyter for their support in establishing and developing the Prize.

 

 

The 2024 BRAIS Prize in the Study of Islam and the Muslim World

 

The British Association for Islamic Studies (BRAIS) is delighted to announce the 2024 round of the BRAIS Prize in the Study of Islam and the Muslim World.

This international prize is awarded annually to the best doctoral thesis or unpublished first monograph based on a doctoral thesis. English-language submissions on any aspect of the academic study of Islam and the Muslim world, past and present, including Muslim-minority societies are accepted. Applicants can be based in any country, and manuscripts will be assessed on the basis of scholarly quality and originality.

The award includes a cash prize of £1000 which will be officially presented at the Annual Conference of BRAIS. The selection process will be undertaken by a nine-member prize committee comprising established academics from across the field. The winning candidate will be notified by September 2024.

Rules and Regulations: 

  1. To be eligible, a submission must either be a doctoral thesis, or an unpublished first monograph based on a doctoral thesis. The thesis must have been completed, successfully defended, and accepted no more than two years before the submission deadline. The thesis must have been submitted as part of the requirements for a doctoral degree at any university in the world.
  2. The subject(s) covered by the submission should fall within the remit of BRAIS. For details, see: www.brais.ac.uk/about-brais/about-us. The Prize Committee will make the final decision on whether submissions are of sufficient relevance.
  3. Submissions should not be scheduled for publication at any time before or during the competition.
  4. An award ceremony will be organised at the BRAIS Annual Conference.
  5. The BRAIS Prize is open to BRAIS members from any country. There is no age limit.
  6. Submissions are accepted in English only (with selections in other languages, where relevant), and must adhere to internationally recognised standards and conventions of academic writing, including of transliteration. Entries must include:
    1. Application form which can be downloaded here: BRAIS Prize 2024 Application Form (528.5 KB Word)
    2. The manuscript. The minimum word limit is 80,000 words. There is no maximum limit. The thesis must be submitted in anonymised form, with all references to the author and his/her institution, acknowledgements and any other material that might help to identify the origins of the thesis removed, within reason. This is to maximise impartiality during the review process.
    3. The applicant’s curriculum vitae, of a maximum of 2 pages.
    4. A statement, of a maximum of 750 words, summarising the submission and highlighting its originality and contribution to the field.
    5. A scanned copy of the formal confirmation of the completion, successful defence and acceptance of the doctoral thesis from the awarding institution. If in doubt on the nature of this document, please enquire at your institution. 
  7. Items a-d should be submitted in PDF format. All files must contain the applicant’s surname in the file name. Documents must be submitted to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. by 5pm GMT Friday 12 January 2024
  8. The applicant should also arrange for the supervisor or another academic, who is more senior than the applicant and is familiar with the submission, to submit a supporting statement that highlights its contributions to the field. This should be submitted by the supervisor or senior academic confidentially and directly to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. by 5pm GMT Friday 12 January 2024. The full name of the applicant should be stated in the title of the email.
  9. Failure to follow all submission requirements will result in an automatic disqualification.

All submissions are vigorously and anonymously reviewed by experts in the relevant field. The reports from reviewers help the Prize Committee to undertake the selection process.

 

The Prize Committee

Omar Anchassi (University of Bern)

Sariya Cheruvallil-Contractor (Coventry University)

Robert Gleave (University of Exeter)

Jon Hoover (University of Nottingham)

Carool Kersten (KU Leuven)

Anna McSweeny (Trinity College Dublin, University of Dublin)

Judith Pfeiffer (University of Bonn)

Saeko Yazaki (University of Glasgow), Chair

 

Prize Coordinator

Adam Ramadhan (Al-Mahdi Institute)

 

Former Prize Committee Members

Anthony Allison (University of Glasgow)

Glaire Anderson (University of Edinburgh)

Nicolai Sinai (Oxford University)

James Piscatori (Durham University)

Sophie Gilliat-Ray (Cardiff University)

Ayman Shihadeh (SOAS, University of London), Chair 2016-2018

The Prize Committee wishes to convey its gratitude to Dr Ayman Shihadeh for his hard work and unfailing patience as Chair during the initial years of the Prize, and for his vision in establishing it in collaboration with De Gruyter. 

The BRAIS Prize was originally called the BRAIS-De Gruyter Prize until 2022 and the BRAIS Officers and Prize Committee would like to express special thanks to De Gruyter for their support in establishing and developing the Prize.

 

 

The 2026 BRAIS Prize in the Study of Islam and the Muslim World

 

The British Association for Islamic Studies (BRAIS) is delighted to announce the 2026 round of the BRAIS Prize in the Study of Islam and the Muslim World.

This international prize is awarded annually to one outstanding doctoral thesis. English-language submissions on any aspect of the academic study of Islam and the Muslim world, past and present, including Muslim-minority societies are accepted. Applicants can be based in any country.

Manuscripts will be assessed on the basis of scholarly quality and originality, rigour in scholarship, use of source material, contribution to the field and clarity of expression.

The award includes a cash prize of £1000 which will be officially presented at the Annual Conference of BRAIS. The selection process will be undertaken by the prize committee comprising established academics from across the field. The winning candidate will be notified by September 2026.

Rules and Regulations: 

  1. To be eligible, a submission must be a doctoral thesis which has been completed, successfully defended, and accepted no more than two years before the submission deadline. The thesis must have been submitted as part of the requirements for a doctoral degree at any university in the world.
  2. The subject(s) covered by the submission should fall within the remit of BRAIS. For details, see: www.brais.ac.uk/about-brais/about-us. The Prize Committee will make the final decision on whether submissions are of sufficient relevance.
  3. An award ceremony will be organised at the BRAIS Annual Conference.
  4. The BRAIS Prize is open to BRAIS members from any country. There is no age limit.
  5. Submissions are accepted in English only and must adhere to internationally recognised standards and conventions of academic writing, including of transliteration. Entries must include:
    1. Application form which can be downloaded here: BRAIS Prize 2026 Application Form
    2. The manuscript. The minimum word limit is 80,000 words. There is no maximum limit. The thesis must be submitted in anonymised form, with all references to the author and his/her institution, acknowledgements and any other material that might help to identify the origins of the thesis removed, within reason. This is to maximise impartiality during the review process.
    3. The applicant’s curriculum vitae, of a maximum of 2 pages.
    4. A statement, of a maximum of 750 words, summarising the submission and highlighting its originality and contribution to the field.
    5. A scanned copy of the formal confirmation of the completion, successful defence and acceptance of the doctoral thesis from the awarding institution. If in doubt on the nature of this document, please enquire at your institution. 
  6. Items a-d should be submitted in PDF format. All files must contain the applicant’s surname in the file name. Documents must be submitted to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. by 5pm GMT Friday 30 January 2026
  7. The applicant should also arrange for the supervisor or another academic, who is more senior than the applicant and is familiar with the submission, to submit a supporting statement that highlights its contributions to the field. This should be submitted by the supervisor or senior academic confidentially and directly to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. by 5pm GMT Friday 30 January 2026. The full name of the applicant should be stated in the title of the email.
  8. Failure to follow all submission requirements will result in an automatic disqualification.

All submissions are vigorously and anonymously reviewed by experts in the relevant field. The reports from reviewers help the Prize Committee to undertake the selection process.

 

The Prize Committee

Sariya Cheruvallil-Contractor (Coventry University)

Nahyan Fancy (University of Exeter)

Jon Hoover (University of Nottingham)

Anna McSweeny (Trinity College Dublin, University of Dublin)

Jorgen Neilsen (University of Birmingham)

Judith Pfeiffer (University of Bonn)

Yossef Rapoport (Queen Mary University of London)

Saeko Yazaki (University of Glasgow), Chair 

 

Former Prize Committee Members

Omar Anchassi (University of Bern)

Anthony Allison (University of Glasgow)

Glaire Anderson (University of Edinburgh)

Carool Kersten (KU Leuven)

Nicolai Sinai (Oxford University)

Rob Gleave (University of Exeter)

James Piscatori (Durham University)

Sophie Gilliat-Ray (Cardiff University)

Ayman Shihadeh (SOAS, University of London), Chair 2016-2018

The BRAIS Prize was originally called the BRAIS-De Gruyter Prize until 2022 and the BRAIS Officers and Prize Committee would like to express special thanks to De Gruyter for their support in establishing and developing the Prize.

 

Former Prize Committee Coordinators

Anthony Allison

Omar Anchassi

Adam Ramadhan

 

 

The 2025 BRAIS Prize in the Study of Islam and the Muslim World

 

The British Association for Islamic Studies (BRAIS) is delighted to announce the 2025 round of the BRAIS Prize in the Study of Islam and the Muslim World.

This international prize is awarded annually to one outstanding doctoral thesis. English-language submissions on any aspect of the academic study of Islam and the Muslim world, past and present, including Muslim-minority societies are accepted. Applicants can be based in any country.

Manuscripts will be assessed on the basis of scholarly quality and originality, rigour in scholarship, use of source material, contribution to the field and clarity of expression.

The award includes a cash prize of £1000 which will be officially presented at the Annual Conference of BRAIS. The selection process will be undertaken by a eight-member prize committee comprising established academics from across the field. The winning candidate will be notified by September 2025.

Rules and Regulations: 

  1. To be eligible, a submission must be a doctoral thesis which has been completed, successfully defended, and accepted no more than two years before the submission deadline. The thesis must have been submitted as part of the requirements for a doctoral degree at any university in the world.
  2. The subject(s) covered by the submission should fall within the remit of BRAIS. For details, see: www.brais.ac.uk/about-brais/about-us. The Prize Committee will make the final decision on whether submissions are of sufficient relevance.
  3. An award ceremony will be organised at the BRAIS Annual Conference.
  4. The BRAIS Prize is open to BRAIS members from any country. There is no age limit.
  5. Submissions are accepted in English only (with selections in other languages, where relevant), and must adhere to internationally recognised standards and conventions of academic writing, including of transliteration. Entries must include:
    1. Application form which can be downloaded here: 
    2. The manuscript. The minimum word limit is 80,000 words. There is no maximum limit. The thesis must be submitted in anonymised form, with all references to the author and his/her institution, acknowledgements and any other material that might help to identify the origins of the thesis removed, within reason. This is to maximise impartiality during the review process.
    3. The applicant’s curriculum vitae, of a maximum of 2 pages.
    4. A statement, of a maximum of 750 words, summarising the submission and highlighting its originality and contribution to the field.
    5. A scanned copy of the formal confirmation of the completion, successful defence and acceptance of the doctoral thesis from the awarding institution. If in doubt on the nature of this document, please enquire at your institution. 
  6. Items a-d should be submitted in PDF format. All files must contain the applicant’s surname in the file name. Documents must be submitted to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. by 5pm GMT Friday 24 January 2025
  7. The applicant should also arrange for the supervisor or another academic, who is more senior than the applicant and is familiar with the submission, to submit a supporting statement that highlights its contributions to the field. This should be submitted by the supervisor or senior academic confidentially and directly to This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. by 5pm GMT Friday 24 January 2025. The full name of the applicant should be stated in the title of the email.
  8. Failure to follow all submission requirements will result in an automatic disqualification.

All submissions are vigorously and anonymously reviewed by experts in the relevant field. The reports from reviewers help the Prize Committee to undertake the selection process.

 

The Prize Committee

Sariya Cheruvallil-Contractor (Coventry University)

Nahyan Fancy (University of Exeter)

Robert Gleave (University of Exeter)

Jon Hoover (University of Nottingham)

Anna McSweeny (Trinity College Dublin, University of Dublin)

Jorgen Neilsen (University of Birmingham)

Judith Pfeiffer (University of Bonn)

Saeko Yazaki (University of Glasgow), Chair

 

Prize Coordinator

Adam Ramadhan (Leiden University)

 

Former Prize Committee Members

Omar Anchassi (University of Bern)

Anthony Allison (University of Glasgow)

Glaire Anderson (University of Edinburgh)

Carool Kersten (KU Leuven)

Nicolai Sinai (Oxford University)

James Piscatori (Durham University)

Sophie Gilliat-Ray (Cardiff University)

Ayman Shihadeh (SOAS, University of London), Chair 2016-2018

The BRAIS Prize was originally called the BRAIS-De Gruyter Prize until 2022 and the BRAIS Officers and Prize Committee would like to express special thanks to De Gruyter for their support in establishing and developing the Prize.

The British Association for Islamic Studies (BRAIS) and De Gruyter are delighted to announce the outcome of the sixth (2022) round of the BRAIS – De Gruyter Prize in the Study of Islam and the Muslim World.

The winning submission was:

 
Elizabeth Grace Price
Yale University
 
The Barāhima’s Dilemma:
Ibn al-Rāwandī’s Kitāb al-Zumurrud and the Epistemological Turn in the Debate on Prophecy
 
 
Abstract
 

After the turn of the 10th century, Muslim theologians began to cite a puzzling thought experiment in their discussions of prophecy (nubuwwa), which took the form of the following two-horned dilemma: either a prophet conveys what is in accordance with reason, so they would be superfluous, or a prophet conveys what is contrary to reason, so they would be rejected. Theologians usually cited this dilemma on the authority of a group called the “Barāhima”, who apparently did not recognise the need for prophets or revealed scriptures in either case, since they believed that reason alone could provide humans with all the theological and moral knowledge that they required. So, who were these so-called “Barāhima”? Did they refer to Brahmans as the orthography of their name would suggest? Or to an entirely different group? And how did they become spokespersons for this highly incisive challenge to prophecy?

This dissertation seeks to answer these questions by charting the evolution of the Barāhima as a topos or a ‘thing to think with’ in early Islamic thought. In particular, it explores the historical and discursive processes that led to the formation of the Barāhima’s dilemma, and assesses the impact that this thought experiment had on the broader development of Islamic theology, with a special focus on Muʿtazilī kalām. In the process, it demonstrates the pivotal role that Ibn al-Rāwandī’s controversial “Book of the Emerald” (Kitāb al-Zumurrud) played in the dissemination of the Barāhima’s critiques and, more crucially, in facilitating an epistemological turn in how Muslim theologians came to conceptualise and defend the institution of prophecy. When faced with the arch-rationalism of the prophecy-denying Barāhima, theologians were not only pressed to explain precisely why rational agents required the input of revelation, but to also identify the existence of a specific epistemic gap that only the intervention of a prophet could fill. Whether a theologian could successfully defend the necessity of prophetic revelation would ultimately depend, therefore, on how successfully they could define and delineate the functions of the human intellect. A debate about whether humans required the guidance of prophets thus evolved into a debate about what humans could and could not know by their own means.

 

2022 Honorable Mention

Aziza Shanazarova

Indiana University-Bloomington

A Female Saint in Muslim Polemics: Agha-yi Buzurg and her Legacy in Early Modern Central Asia